Concept that applies to finding people you lost and restoring operational issues...
Let's imagine you are taking a walk through a forest with your child.
Everything is fine.
You have a route in mind. The weather is good. The child is happily exploring the world around them.
Then something happens.
As children tend to do, your child becomes fascinated by something. A bird. A tree. An imaginary adventure.
A few moments later you look around.
And you have lost each other.
Your first instinct is often to search everywhere.
The child does the same.
Both of you keep moving.
Ironically increasing the chances of continuously missing each other.
Fortunately there is a simple principle used by hikers, rescue teams, military units and many experienced parents:
When you lose track of each other, return to the last place where you know you were together.
Not the place where you think the other person might be.
Not the place where you hope they are.
The last place where you are certain you were together.
Once both parties return to that point, they reconnect.
Problem solved.
The principle is simple:
When certainty is lost, return to the last point where certainty existed.
Now let's move from the forest to a transaction processing system.
Transactions 1, 2 and 3 are processed correctly.
Then transaction 4 suddenly takes an unexpected route.
Transaction 5 appears to have been changed.
The user receives an unexpected outcome and raises an alarm.
The natural reaction is predictable:
Let's fix transaction 4.
Let's repair transaction 5.
Let's move on.
But there is a more important question.
Do we still have certainty?
Do we know exactly what happened?
Can we prove how transaction 5 was affected?
Can we prove there were no downstream consequences?
Can we prove that data integrity remains intact?
If the answer is not an unequivocal "yes", then repairing the visible symptoms may actually make things worse.
Because once we overwrite information, reconstruct records or make assumptions about what happened, we may destroy the very evidence needed to understand the problem.
And with that, we lose the ability to fully restore integrity.
This is why operationally mature environments often use a different response.
Rather than correcting the visible error, they identify the last known-good state.
The equivalent of returning to the place in the forest where parent and child were still together.
If we know transactions 1, 2 and 3 are correct, but we are no longer certain about transaction 4 onwards, then we roll back to transaction 3.
Not because it is the fastest solution.
Because it is the safest path back to certainty.
From there we rebuild.
Transaction by transaction.
Step by step.
Verifying that integrity is maintained throughout the process.
Only when certainty has been restored can confidence in the result be restored as well.
I often observe teams focusing on error correction when they should first be focusing on integrity preservation.
Yet integrity is the foundation that makes correction possible.
Without integrity, every subsequent ownership record, calculation, reconciliation, settlement instruction, position or audit trail becomes questionable.
The challenge is not removing every mistake.
Mistakes will always happen.
The challenge is ensuring that when they do happen, we know exactly how to get back to a trusted state.
Relevance for DLT
This principle becomes even more relevant in distributed ledger environments.
Distributed ledgers do not eliminate operational mistakes.
Data can still be entered incorrectly.
Software can still contain defects.
Business logic can still fail.
Participants can still make mistakes.
Which raises an important design question:
When certainty is lost, how do we return to the last state that we know was correct?
The answer should not be designed after launch.
It should be designed before launch.
Because operational resilience is not demonstrated by never making mistakes.
It is demonstrated by having a safe and reliable path back to certainty when mistakes inevitably occur.
The lesson from the forest turns out to be surprisingly universal:
When you no longer know where you are, don't continue from assumptions. Retrace your steps to the last point where you were certain.
In forests.
In military operations.
In software systems.
In financial market infrastructures.
And increasingly, in distributed ledger solutions.
#CartoonsInFinance #OperationalResilience #DataIntegrity #DigitalAssets #DLT #Fintech #MarketInfrastructure #OperationalRisk #Technology #FinancialMarkets
Originally published on LinkedIn. View original article.