Markets explained · 2026-06-18

🧠 Cartoons in Finance #17 — Why your “gut” beats your spreadsheet

Illustrated story by Maurice van Tilburg – Glimne

When I became a first-time manager (Euroclear, around 2000), I thought good decision-making meant one thing:

Be rational. Structured. Analytical.

And when things got complex?

👉 Add more logic 👉 Build better frameworks 👉 Push harder on the analysis

Sounds familiar?

🏠 The illusion of rational decisions

Take something simple: buying a house.

Seems straightforward… until you list the variables:

  • Price

  • Location

  • Light

  • Neighbours

  • Layout

  • Garden

  • Renovation cost

  • Smell (!)

  • Opinions of others

  • “Seller vibe”

Suddenly you’re juggling 10+ dimensions.

So we do what we’ve been taught:

✅ Build a comparison table ✅ Score each option ✅ Add pluses and minuses

And yet…

When you visit the houses, you already know:

❤️ “Yes, this is the one.” 😐 “This is fine.” 🤔 “Something feels off.”


⚖️ Rational vs. “feeling”

In the Western business world, we’ve learned:

Rational = objective, defensible, smart Feeling = subjective, vague, a bit… risky

So we tend to trust the spreadsheet more than ourselves.


🔬 What science actually says

Here’s the interesting part.

Even before Kahneman’s Thinking, Fast and Slow, psychologist Ap Dijksterhuis showed something powerful:

  • Our rational brain can handle ~7 decision criteria effectively

  • Our subconscious can process far more (massively more)

In experiments:

  • People choosing based on analysis made worse decisions

  • People choosing based on subconscious processing did better

👉 Especially when decisions were complex

In short:

The more complex the decision → the less effective pure rational thinking becomes.


🤯 So… should we ignore logic?

No.

But we’ve likely been using things in the wrong order.


✅ A smarter way to decide (that actually works)

Here’s a simple 4-step approach I now use (and wish I had known earlier):

1. 📅 Set a decision moment

Give yourself a clear deadline (e.g., “I decide next weekend”)


2. 🧠 Feed your subconscious

Over several days:

  • Talk to people with different views

  • Read relevant information

  • Reflect (without forcing conclusions)

👉 Don’t decide yet—just load the system.


3. ❤️ Listen to your feeling

At decision time:

  • Step back

  • Ask yourself: Which option feels right?

Not perfect. Not explainable. Just… right.


4. ✅ Use logic as a sanity check

Now bring back rational thinking:

  • Is this financially viable?

  • Are there obvious red flags?

  • Is there some form of bias that interferes with my feelings?

  • Does it pass basic constraints?

👉 Not to decide 👉 But to avoid mistakes


🚀 Why this matters (especially for entrepreneurs)

If you're building a company, leading people, or navigating uncertainty:

  • You rarely face “simple” decisions

  • You’re constantly balancing many variables

  • Speed and judgment matter

Trying to out-analyze complexity can slow you down — or mislead you.

👉 Your subconscious is not a weakness 👉 It’s an advanced processing system


💡 Final thought

We’ve been trained to believe:

“If I can’t explain it rationally, it’s probably wrong.”

Science suggests the opposite might often be true.

If the decision is complex, your best thinking may already have happened… below the surface.

Curious—do you recognize this?

Do you trust your “feeling” in big decisions, or do you still default to the spreadsheet?

Originally published on LinkedIn. View original article.