A short story about black boxes, white boxes, and why data provenance matters.
A few weeks ago, we bought a modern “intelligent” scale for our house.
You step on it—and wow. Weight, BMI, body fat, muscle mass, bone mass, heart rate, biological age… pages and pages of numbers. Very impressive.
Then one number stood out.
Visceral fat: 11. Super high. üö®
That surprised me. I’m not overweight. I’ve been vegetarian for 14+ years. I cycle daily, walk the dog, do sports. Even more interesting: my wife’s numbers were fine. Mine stayed stubbornly the same—day after day—no matter what.
So I started wondering: how good is this data, really?
I went to the doctor. Blood test. Ten days later, results came back.
No signal at all related to visceral fat.
Just when I thought I could walk away… something else appeared: elevated cholesterol.
That one hit closer to home. My father suffered from cholesterol‑related angina pectoris. Suddenly, this data changed how I think about my own behaviour and long‑term risk—even knowing I already do many of the “right” things.
What struck me most wasn’t just what was measured—but how.
Black‚Äëbox data vs white‚Äëbox data
The scale works by:
Measuring weight
Adding some basic inputs from an app
Possibly sensing impedance or heartbeat
And then… modeling a lot of the rest, based on statistical correlations from large populations
In other words: üëâ it derives many numbers rather than directly measuring them.
That’s what I’d call black‑box data:
Indirect
Model‚Äëdriven
Useful when nothing else is available
But opaque in how conclusions are reached
The blood test works differently. It:
Directly measures values in my blood
Uses known biochemical methods
Lets you look into the system itself
That’s white‑box data:
Direct
System‚Äënative
Transparent in origin
White‑box data isn’t perfect—it can be incomplete, biased toward what we know how to measure, slow, or expensive. Black‑box data isn’t “bad”—often it’s the only thing we have early on.
The difference is what kind of decisions you base on it.
Startup funding data: a familiar example
This distinction becomes very familiar in the startup world.
On one side, we have funding databases built largely from:
News articles
Press releases
Websites
Announcements and ecosystem inputs
Platforms like Dealroom or CB Insights do an impressive job turning fragmented signals into usable insight. This is largely black‚Äëbox data: scraped, inferred, estimated.
On the other side, there’s investor‑reported data:
Academic analyses using raw VC records (e.g. long‚Äëterm exit studies)
Aggregated investment data from associations like NVP
Full reporting from institutions like EIF, based on actual fund structures
That’s much closer to white‑box data: slower, harder to get—but grounded in what actually happened.
Both are useful. Problems start when we forget which one we are looking at.
Who owns the shares, really? Second example.
There are services that estimate share ownership by combining:
Public filings
News
Custodian disclosures
Partner data
They provide a smooth, commercial experience—but what they show is still reconstructed ownership.
SRD II changes the model.
Under SRD II, an issuer can request shareholder identification through the actual settlement infrastructure. The request travels down the chain—from CSD, through intermediaries—until it reaches the final investor, who then reports.
Less glossy. Much more white‚Äëbox.
And crucially: it tells companies who really owns their shares.
Reports, surveys, and big decisions
Every day we read reports about:
The economy
Innovation
Labour markets
Competitiveness
Geopolitics
Many are based heavily on surveys, combined with high‚Äëlevel economic data.
Surveys can be incredibly valuable—but they are also:
Context‚Äësensitive
Dependent on wording
A mix of facts, perceptions, opinions, and interests
That makes them, by nature, black‚Äëbox inputs.
The issue isn’t that they’re used. The issue is when we treat them as white‑box truth and then build very confident policy conclusions—or very large funding programs—on top.
As the saying goes:
Be careful not to build cathedrals on uncertain foundations.
A simple takeaway
Not all data is created equal.
Some data is derived, some is measured. Some data lives outside the system, some inside it. Most real‚Äëworld datasets sit somewhere in between.
Understanding where your data comes from is at least as important as the number itself—especially when decisions have long‑term consequences.
That’s the idea behind this edition of Cartoons in Finance, a bit personal but hope you like it.
Originally published on LinkedIn. View original article.