Management is not a throne. It’s a decision discipline.
This experience was taken from my experience at start of my career. I was frustrated that my views were not heard. And when I finally became a manager I thought it was finally my moment to drive the team my way... Fortunately it was Leen van Rij from KPMG as an external auditor that taught me a tool that helps decision making and finding a way to onboard people's view and still take a decision....
More often when people get promoted into management, something curious often happens.
The role is subconsciously interpreted as status. A signal that you now “know better”. That you are entitled to act according to your own views.
That’s usually where things start to go wrong.
Managers slowly lose touch with how work really happens. They rely on old mental models. They underestimate their own bias. And teams get demotivated — not necessarily because of what was decided, but because nobody understands why.
In its most essential form, management is not about authority. It is about making the right decisions — for and with the company.
And here’s the uncomfortable truth: as a manager, the decisions that end up on your desk are usually the worst ones.
If a decision was easy, someone else would already have taken it.
What lands on your table are the messy cases: different views, no optimal solution, incomplete data, conflicting interests, time pressure, political noise. And regardless of what you decide, there will always be bystanders who criticise — even if they never had to make the call themselves.
So the real skill of management is not having opinions. It is creating clarity, fairness and explainability in decision-making.
About 35 years ago, a senior manager at KPMG taught me a simple but powerful way to do this. I’ve used it ever since — as a manager, CEO, and when working with leadership teams.
It consists of five steps.
First: Describe the situation. What actually happened? What are the relevant events and timeline? What key information do we have today? Where do views diverge, and why does this require escalation?
This step sounds trivial — but it often reveals that people disagree because they are reacting to different realities.
Second: Define the real problem. Not the symptoms. Not the loudest complaint.
What are the underlying root causes? Which values or interests are in conflict? What information or guidance is missing? And why were these issues not addressed earlier?
If you can’t articulate the real problem, every solution will be accidental.
Third: Assess impact and size. Not every problem deserves senior airtime.
What is truly at stake? What are the consequences if nothing happens? Is there urgency or time pressure — and why? What risks materialise if this is delayed?
This helps leadership prioritise, allocate attention, and involve the right people — instead of reacting emotionally.
Fourth: Develop solutions. This is where most decision processes fail.
Good decisions are rarely about a single criterion. Customer impact, strategy, financials, values, risk — they all matter, and they often conflict.
By explicitly mapping decision criteria and scoring options with stakeholders, something interesting happens: people may still disagree with the outcome, but they recognise the fairness of the process.
And almost always, when you work through the obvious options carefully, new options emerge — solutions that preserve the upside while mitigating key downsides.
That is the moment when decision-making turns from politics into problem-solving.
Fifth: Make a recommendation. Look at the most important criteria. Which option scores best there?
That becomes your recommendation — with explicit compensating measures for the downsides. If other groups prefer a different option, surface it transparently and explain which criteria would justify choosing it.
Then share the decision — and the reasoning — widely. People don’t need perfection. They need understanding.
Two additional lessons shaped my own approach.
1) Edward de Bono once said: A difference of opinion is always a difference in information, experience or values.
There are no stupid people. So when someone disagrees, the most productive response is curiosity: Which of those three have I not yet fully understood?
At Euronext, my nickname turned out to be “Columbo”. I kept asking questions — sometimes so much that people assumed I already knew the answer. Often, I didn’t. But asking the questions made better decisions possible.
2) At Techleap, this approach helped resolve years of tension around fragmented startup ecosystem data. Different organisations defended their numbers. Everyone was right — and everyone was stuck.
By reframing the problem and criteria, we found a new solution: shared high-level data for the public narrative, combined with space for each party’s proprietary insights. The debate shifted from “whose numbers are correct” to “what do the numbers tell us, and what should we do”.
3) Now in a time of AI that helps you it is easy to ask for writing a memo. But that does not guarantee that it is the best outcome, that complexities get addressed and that other people's views get onboarded. So make sure you follow some process to ensure you onboard peoples view and still build a 'neutral' and structured proposal. And of course AI can help you do that, for example by asking the question to check whether the structure of your story addresses biases or certain elements are missing.
That supports the power of structured decision-making.
Management is not about sitting on a throne and pointing. It’s about navigating complexity with humility, discipline and transparency.
And yes ‚Äî cartoons help. üôÇ
Originally published on LinkedIn. View original article.